Etsy Secret Autumn swap

I am a little anxious about it. There is something nervewracking about making a gift (or buying one) for a stranger, never mind someone you know. I love the idea of it though. My swap giftee seems a little hard to shop for, but I really want to get something good. I almost wish there was a price cap on this too. I have some little things chosen already, but I would like one bigger gift to include. I guess my biggest fear is that she wouldn't like it.

To my swap partner (who has me a giftee): I like everything. I love soft handspun yarn, especially funky ones the most, right now; I love lotions/candles, vanilla is my favorite scent. I love stuffed things. Sunflowers, roses, fall items. Not picky.